Help

Every price is the same whether you buy one or a hundred. Enter SHOW at checkout and it takes 20% off everything on the site, whether or not you have met Gary at a show.

Buying for a shop? Dealers have their own trade pricing, so bring your tax ID to a show and Gary will set you up.

Tariffs are moving supplier prices, so ours can change without notice. If a change ever affects an order you have already placed, we will contact you before it ships.

We ship within the continental US. Orders over $100 ship free, counted after your code, and anything under that pays a flat rate by weight, which you see at checkout before you pay. Tracking comes by email as soon as your order ships.

The stock on this site is the stock in Gary's storeroom, updated as he counts it. When he packs for a show, those items come off the site until he is back, so nobody is promised a box that is sitting in his van. If an item is not on the shelf, its page says so before you order.

Checkout runs on Shopify, so you can pay by card or with Shop Pay, and your card details go to Shopify rather than to us.

If something arrives damaged, or is not what you ordered, email contact@garyscardsupplies.com with your order number and we will sort it out with you.

Gary works card shows across Pennsylvania and Ohio. The show schedule has every date he will be there.

Email contact@garyscardsupplies.com, or catch Gary at the next show.